Beautiful location. Great room, very comfortable and modern for a good price.

Hard to find and then find where to go to get room key, as we didn't know it was part of the big hotel next door.

The lodges are located directly next to Carberry Tower, which means you are able to enjoy all the comforts, excellent food and fabulous company of the Carberry Tower staff. Beautiful gardens surround the lodges and Carberry Tower, which are set back from the road, as well as being a short drive to nearby attractions.

Good value accommodation in the middle of a forest.

Handy for visiting our son in Musselburgh.

Very cramped, but it served our purpose. The bed was against the wall, but it was on castors so we moved it away so I could get out of bed more easily in the night. Standard kettle plus tiny sink = Michael Macintyre experience! but there are plastic cups in the 'bathroom', so used those to fill the kettle. The lodges are in peaceful surroundings - the other guests were quiet, so it was a good experience.

Comfort and space in the room - every facillity that I wanted

I thought I had ordered a packed breakfast but nothing appeared and I could not get hold of anybody on reception

Its locations and tranquility

The experience way exceeded my expectations. Friendly and helpful staff. Very interesting history. Wonderfull country feeling but close enough to frequent and safe public transport.

A few too many foreigners (eastern block). I know it is near impossible but would have appreciated a full Scottish staff to compliment the ambience of the Tower and maybe a hint of tartan or traditional dress for staff uniforms.

Comfortable ; quiet- located in a park.Good clean facilities. The staff were very friendly and helpful. Useful free WIFI - strong signal.

Nothing we did not like.

Very good value for money Clean and functional

Bit far out but still good value

very friendly staff and very very helpful would book again told family and friends how good it was in the country nice and quite and clean good facilties

The location was excellent. Beautiful countryside , with easy access to edinburgh city centre .

The structure of the room was quite awkward and not user friendly. The sloping ceiling was intrusive and somewhat claustrophobic. The shower cubicle was so cramped it was virtually impossible to wash oneself properly, accessing one's feet was entirely in the domain of the contortionist. The extractor fan in the bathroom was loud enough to wake the dead. The toilet brush fell apart and was filthy with the produce of previous occupants. The siting of the mirror in the bathroom made it necessary for me to kneel down to shave. I was unable to park ouside the accomodation because all the spaces were taken , some by what appeared to be builders vans .

Clean comfortable & lovely friendly staff, really enjoyed the stay there

Location in a country estate, yet close to the city Facilities available on site to guests Historic building Wonderful staff Highly competitive rate for room High quality breakfast

Paying extra for breakfast

Being in the proximity of Carberry Tower which is truly amazing ...

Uncomfortable bed

Very good value for money In clean well presented bedroom . Nice staff very friendly .unexpectedly high standard at affordable price a joy will defo be back .

Shower a bit rubbish